Eltingville

Score Breakdown

About this Neighborhood

Eltingville scores 43, one of the stronger showings in this set, powered by a robust 29 restaurants, 9 grocery options, 4 fitness spots, and 2 parks. With nearly thirty places to eat and ample groceries, this is a genuinely commercial, do-your-errands-locally kind of area, and the 2 coffee shops mean mornings can start with a walkable cup. It reads as one of the busier neighborhoods here. The food leans Italian, Japanese, and pizzeria-heavy, with Patrizia's of Staten Island, Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza and Trattoria, and Ocean Sushi topping a Yelp average of 4.3 across more than 4,600 reviews. Foursquare tastes back that up with pizzerias, Italian and Japanese restaurants, delis, and a butcher. It's a practical, food-rich area that delivers on day-to-day convenience.